For the last couple weeks, I have been reading up on the proposed “West Michigan Air Alliance.” After considerable thought, I have decided that I am firmly opposed to the proposed ‘Alliance.’ Below, I have outlined some rationale for my position on the issue.
The first red-flag should be that the ring-leader of the effort to consolidate all the West Michigan regional airports is non-other than former GOP Gubernatorial Candidate and former Amway CEO and President of Windquest Group, Dick DeVos.
I say this because anytime the cheerleaders for a massive change in transportation policy are solely wealthy business people (many Billionaires), I question what it will do to small business and the working-class. According to several sources, the new alliance is made up of business executives from all over West Michigan: Grand Rapids, Lansing, Kalamazoo, and Traverse City. Nonetheless, it is important to note that all proponents are wealthy individuals or large-scale businesses.
The aim of this group of wealthy business executives is to consolidate all of the West Michigan airports to become a larger and more “competitive” airport. The hope is that a consolidated Grand Rapids airport would be better able to compete with Chicago and Detroit, provide more competitive fares, and more travel options. The business executives are hoping for cheaper business travel flights for its employees and stakeholders and economic growth for the Grand Rapids-area.
Although all these positive changes are true, they primarily hold true for Grand Rapids (and only Grand Rapids). Just as in business, when the market share in one company grows, it’s largely at the depletion of some other entity’s cut of the pie. In the case of the alliance, the smaller regional airports would close and the Kalamazoo area would fall prey to Grand Rapids political and business elite. In turn, local businesses and hotels would lose customers. Many of the businesses along Portage Road and hotels on Sprinkle Road (near I-94), depend heavily on airport travelers. Furthermore, although the alliance claims that jobs would be transferred from the other area airports to Grand Rapids, the Kalamazoo area will lose its airport employees, any nearby dependent business jobs, and potential travelers. (more…)